mdd -“Is he be’chlal “achicha”? Obviously, yes. The same is with a real tinok she’nishba.”
I agree with the sometimes Shoggeg part, but I’m not sure if s/o who doesn’t keep anything is still “Amecha”. I think I have a Diyuk from the Chofetz Chaim like this but I’m not sure yet. I spent some time learning the C.C., but not enough. He is Marich on this Inyan a lot in a couple of places in the C.C.
“Health, look in Yore Deah 159”
Bli Neder when I have some time.