cherrybim: “Are you saying that the Rav Hamachshir for kosher gelatin requires that it come from animals that had sh’chita?”
Absolutely. The Poskim who forbid gelatin from a beheima temeia would equalyy forbid from a neveila. All Hechsherim follow the machmir opinions, including Rav Belsky and Rav Shachter at the OU.
“Hello, is that a new shita?”
Not at all.
“I didn’t permit transformed foods, poskim have.
I have not said anything anywhere that would imply that I hold of any shita that disagrees with Rav Moshe.”
But the Poskim who permit transformed foods are disagreeing with Reb Moshe!!!