Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Three Oaths Essay by Daniel Pinner Reply To: Three Oaths Essay by Daniel Pinner

#2469723
Deprecated: Function seems_utf8 is deprecated since version 6.9.0! Use wp_is_valid_utf8() instead. in /var/www/html/wp-includes/functions.php on line 6131 HaKatan
Participant

SQUARE_ROOT:
Your reply is also Zionist spam.
No major rabbis held that the oaths were no longer in force (though you admit that they were in force before that, contrary to your original post spam).
Cite those original words. There is nothing there.

Regarding Rav Meir Simcha, he likely never actually stated that, as that appeared only in a “Religious Zionist” publication. But even if he did actually state that, that would mean only that peaceful and non-political ascent at that time would not violate the very much in force oath of rebelling against the nations. It would not at all permit a political state nor would it permit ascent en masse.

It’s also imply idiotic to state:
“..the United Nations Organization both voted to establish a Jewish state, in 1920 CE and 1948 CE, so the State of Israel was NOT established by force.”
The simple facts are that the Zionist “State” sure was established by force – lots of force, in fact. The Zionists fought a war of “independence” in 1948, and both fought and terrorized both the British and the Arabs before that. That was not what the League of Nations had stated should happen, of course, but it’s anyways irrelevant because the use of force is forbidden (even according to Rabbi AY Kook) regardless of what the LON/UN/whomever stated.

Stop spamming these boards.