somejew to yb:
…regarding the Avnei Nezer and his point about “not haluche” is a language also used by Satmar Rebbe in Vayoel Moshe to describe the sugya.
But, that doesn’t mean that those gedolimm where – chas v’shulem – kofer in Toras Moshe, rather it means something different than you think …
—
who mentions bichlal ‘kofer betorat moshe here ?
how does that come in to the picture at all ?
—
not halacha means that – it does not have the weight of halacha.
chazal say a person should not get angry
chazal also say one should not 4 amot in reshut harabim
both are chazal
one is halacha
one is not
big difference between the two
the oaths according to avnei nezer and rambam and sh’a and tur and m’b
are like the getting angry – not like the carrying 4 amot.
to point that out is kfira ????
come on … and on top of that …
to be accused of not posting in good faith ???
.
.