Home › Forums › Decaffeinated Coffee › circa 1900: Letter from Lubavitcher Rebbe, the Heresy of “Religious” Zionism › Reply To: circa 1900: Letter from Lubavitcher Rebbe, the Heresy of “Religious” Zionism
some > I’m not claiming any levels. this discussion is about basics of being a yid and claiming membership in klal yisorel.
Minyanim at the kosel usually include all kind of yidden davening together. according to you, a “true charedi” would not be able to daven with all these other Jews. Mahbe all those charedim at the kosel not holding by your opinion? So, your choice is to either acknowledge that or put those charedim in the same cherem you put all non-charedim.
> . I’m sorry you zionism has taken you so far off
I do not consdier myself a zionist, so please take me off your misheberach list.
> if you are attacking me personally here, please point out anywhere I have been anything but polite.
I did not try to trace specific personality. I just see the small cluster of anti-Z posters having very specific characteristics here – they do not bring a gut vort or a gut joke, or ask a good question. All quotes are about condemnation of Z. There is rarely concern about other Yidden, suggestions to say tehilim (as mentioned above – contrary to Satmar Rebbe). In short, there are many posters who bring some story and I, and maybe others, say – I’ve learned something or I’d like to emulate something this poster did. For example, there are chabad posters who defend positions that I find untenable, but I admire their passion in helping other Yidden and in focusing their learning on their Rebbe’s writings.
