Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Starting the Torah from Hachodash Hazeh Reply To: Starting the Torah from Hachodash Hazeh

#2233339
Gedol Hador
Participant

Reb Eliezer, Tosafos doesn’t mean that at all. Tosafos is not saying that someone who doesn’t own land in EY is exempt from bringing the ???? ???: as the ???? ???? points out, there is no ???? for saying this. Rather, as the ??”? explains, they are explaining why R’ Yehuda ben Beseira was not ???? ????; on that they answer that he was ???? from ???? ???? because he didn’t own land in EY, and so was automatically ???? from bringing the ???? ??? because he was nowhere near ??????? on ??? ???.

But even if you would be right that not owning land in EY is an exemption from the ???? of ???? ???, the ?????? would still not have a ????; as even then we could bring the ???? ??? without being ?????, just like someone who is ???? from ???? ???? can still choose to come.

Oh, and by the way, the ????? ?????? of Tosafos is not Me’eloho, but rather Mei’alyoh (from the tail).